Back to Evidence DeskYSR Congress Party
ENతెలుగు
CASE 05Earlier version record required

Submitted case note compared with current candidate file · Kabaddi - version question · 1 candidate record

The case note alleges a Kho-Kho backup, but why does the current file show Kabaddi for both records?

COMPLETE CASE NARRATIVE

What happened, from record to consequence

The case concerns Nimmakayala Swetha, also identified in the submitted note as Koganti Swetha, candidate ID SDSC0002644. The note says she was absent from an initial selection list, later obtained a court direction for consideration under Column 7 of G.O.Ms.No.4, and that the supporting file contained a 2022 Kho-Kho certificate behind a 2005 Kabaddi achievement.

The current candidate PDF supplied for publication does not contain that combination. It shows the 1st Asian Women Kabaddi Championship in 2005 as the highest achievement and the 55th Senior National Kabaddi Championship in 2004 as the supporting lower-level record. Both are Kabaddi, and the backup predates the higher achievement.

That leaves a precise version-history question. If a different-sport 2022 document existed when the selection or reconsideration decision was made, the earlier timestamped file, court order and portal change log must be produced. If no such earlier version exists, the original allegation must be corrected rather than repeated. The current PDF alone does not show the mismatch described in the note.

RECORDS EXAMINED

Candidates covered by this case

Selection / districtCandidate IDNameReference
Sports-quota recordSDSC0002644Nimmakayala Swetha (Koganti Swetha)Kabaddi
DOCUMENTED FACTS

The record, point by point

  • The case note alleges a different-sport 2022 backup and refers to a court order.
  • No copy of that court order is in the supplied evidence set.
  • The current highest-achievement record is Kabaddi, 2005.
  • The current backup record is Kabaddi, 2004.
WHY THIS MATTERS

This case tests whether the portal file changed between initial selection, court-directed consideration and final appointment. A dated version history can confirm or disprove that sequence.

RECORDS THAT MUST BE RELEASED

Publish the initial selection list, cited court order, every timestamped candidate-file version, file hashes, portal change log, evaluator note and final appointment decision.

EVIDENCE MAP

Description first, supporting documents next

  1. C5-N1Pages 1-2 - complete bilingual case narrative, candidate list and documented facts
  2. C5-E1Page 3 - 2005 Asian Women Kabaddi Championship record
  3. C5-E2Page 4 - 2004 Senior National Kabaddi Championship backup