Back to Evidence DeskYSR Congress Party
ENతెలుగు
CASE 03Duplicate silver position

Two certificates compared side by side · Judo - 2019 · 2 candidate records

How can two candidates hold second place in the same age and weight division?

COMPLETE CASE NARRATIVE

What happened, from record to consequence

Candidate SDSC0001645, Talliboina Ramu, and candidate SDSC0018737, Konidena Prudhviraj, each submitted a merit certificate from the Senior Inter-District Judo Tournament for Men and Women at the IGMC Stadium, Vijayawada, dated 1 December 2019.

Both certificates identify the +15 age group and men's -81 kg weight division. On both documents, the recorded place is second. The serial numbers are different, but the competition details, category and result position overlap. A single competition division ordinarily has one silver position unless the organiser created separately recorded pools or sub-divisions.

The bout draw and official result register must show whether there were separate pools, whether one certificate was corrected, or whether the same silver position was entered twice. Until those records are reconciled, both sports-quota evaluations cannot be treated as independently verified.

RECORDS EXAMINED

Candidates covered by this case

Selection / districtCandidate IDNameReference
KrishnaSDSC0001645Talliboina RamuTET qualified
PrakasamSDSC0018737Konidena PrudhvirajTET not shown
DOCUMENTED FACTS

The record, point by point

  • Both certificates are dated 1 December 2019 and name the same Vijayawada venue.
  • Both show the +15 age group.
  • Both show the men's -81 kg division.
  • Both record second place for different candidates.
WHY THIS MATTERS

The medal position affects sports-quota priority. A duplicated silver entry can change the order in which candidates are considered for a limited number of posts.

RECORDS THAT MUST BE RELEASED

Publish the full draw, bout-by-bout results, medal table, certificate register and both candidates' signed DSC verification sheets.

EVIDENCE MAP

Description first, supporting documents next

  1. C3-N1Pages 1-2 - complete bilingual case narrative, candidate list and documented facts
  2. C3-E1Page 3 - Talliboina Ramu certificate
  3. C3-E2Page 4 - Konidena Prudhviraj certificate