Back to Evidence DeskYSR Congress Party
ENతెలుగు
CASE 01Event-record contradiction

Candidate certificates and association letters compared · Judo - 2013 · 4 candidate records

How were certificates issued for a senior event the associations say was not held in Khammam?

COMPLETE CASE NARRATIVE

What happened, from record to consequence

The questioned records belong to Desavath Chandra Naik, Mitnasala Sudharani, Riazulla Nalbandhi and Dakoji Pandu. Each file contains a certificate referring to a Senior Inter-District Judo Championship at Khammam from 19 to 21 October 2013. Those dates, the venue and the senior category are the common foundation of all four records.

The Telangana Judo Association letter says the State Senior Inter-District Championship was conducted at Hyderabad on 28 and 29 December 2013 and that the Khammam event on 19-21 October was only for juniors. A separate Khammam District Judo Association letter, dated 4 July 2026, repeats that only the junior category was held at Khammam and says purported senior-category certificates for that event do not match the information available to the association.

G.O.Ms.No.47 requires the screening authority to confirm a certificate with the issuing body and to cross-check the medal or place through event records. If the event category itself is absent from the associations' records, the source-verification reply, evaluator note and final selection decision become essential. The case therefore asks how all four certificates passed verification and whether any selection was affected.

RECORDS EXAMINED

Candidates covered by this case

Selection / districtCandidate IDNameReference
TET S.No. 207SDSC0018217Desavath Chandra NaikTET 2024 - TET24801526
TET S.No. 206SDSC0020055Mitnasala SudharaniTET 2024 - TET7240383401
TET S.No. 85SDSC0020578Riazulla NalbandhiHPT - 182132501344
Guntur recordSDSC0001036Dakoji PanduTET 2025
DOCUMENTED FACTS

The record, point by point

  • Four files use the same Khammam venue and 19-21 October 2013 dates.
  • The certificates describe a senior inter-district judo event.
  • The state association letter says the senior event was held at Hyderabad on 28-29 December 2013.
  • The district association letter says the Khammam event on the questioned dates was junior-only.
WHY THIS MATTERS

A sports-quota certificate can be assessed only against the real event register, category, medal list and issuing authority. Here, the central event detail is contradicted by both association letters.

RECORDS THAT MUST BE RELEASED

Publish the 2013 event calendar, tournament register, draw sheets, medal list, certificate serial and dispatch registers, issuing-body verification replies, evaluator notes and the selection decision for all four records.

EVIDENCE MAP

Description first, supporting documents next

  1. C1-N1Pages 1-2 - complete bilingual case narrative, candidate list and documented facts
  2. C1-E1Pages 3-4 - Telangana and Khammam association letters
  3. C1-E2Pages 5-12 - four candidate certificate records